Critical Response To Criticism of The Awakening
In “Feminist or Naturalist”, Nancy Walker takes a strong stance against the purpose of this book being formulated on feminism and instead as the perspective of a naturalist on the topic Edna’s “awakening”. Walker uses evidence to examine Edna’s “realization of her sensual nature, not of her equality or freedom as an individual” (Walker 252). Walker also points out Chopin’s use of Creole setting and naturalistic portrayal to depict Edna’s change of behavior and how the Creole society impacted her. By demonstrating how the Creoles “lived a life of sensation and careless enjoyment” as well as being “openly sensual people,” Walker highlights how Chopin strewed from feministic views to more illustrating how an exposure to a different lifestyle can cause one to be “hypnotized” and not able to “control herself” (Walker 255).
As Edna explains at the beginning of the book that “freedom of expression was at first incomprehensible to her,” Chopin reveals Edna’s first naive and help back behavior that is drawn out from Robert (Chopin 12). Even Adele comments to Robert that “She is not one of use; she is not like us. She might make the unfortunate blunder of taking you seriously,” which Walker uses to shine light upon how Edna’s exposure to Robert leads to the realization of expression of feelings (Chopin 29). Furthermore Walker argues that “Edna’s lack of intellectual understanding of her actions” which thus causes her to make “a series of unplanned, unconnected moves” that goes beyond the emotional output of regular Creole people. (Walker 255).
Throughout the book, Chopin also seems to portray other women in the novel as happy and content with their conforming roles in society, which seems to delineate the opposite effect of a feministic belief to break out of gender roles. As a result Chopin represents Edna as a women not of strength and purpose, but like a child where she acts “without a certain amount of reflection which is necessary in this life”, and Walker uses this to rationalize the less and less control Edna has over her decisions and actions leading her to death in her criticism (Walker 256). Walker uses this evidence in order to reason to why Chopin wrote this book, claiming to call attention to “open acceptance of the sensual nature of women”, “exposure to a society”, and “little control over her own destiny” (Walker 256). Walker strongly demoralizes the idea of feminism in The Awakening by analyzing Chopin’s depiction of Edna’s actions and her fatal death at the end of the book.